Disclaimer: This story is a metaphorical response to the recent ruling in the UK against the Christian couple applying for foster care.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2011/feb/28/christian-couple-lose-care-case
I recently purchased a beautiful jigsaw puzzle for my 5 year old daughter. Her and I have always enjoyed doing puzzles together, it is calming and allows for more fruitful conversation and bonding than much of the entertainment options we could use. We usually finished 500 piece puzzles, but this time we decided to embark on finishing our first 1000 piece puzzle together!
The box cover showed that it was a beautiful picture of a sunset over the ocean. You could see birds flying over the horizon, and sailboats filled with people in the distance. On the shore of the beach were children playing in the sand.
We started the puzzle together, but realized, to our dismay, that many of the pieces in our box did not belong to the puzzle we were doing! Some matched perfectly with the colors and pictures displayed on the box. Others, however, clearly did not belong to this set.
The next day I brought the puzzle, with all of its pieces, back to the store and asked to speak to the manager. The store was a quaint little Educational Center, with books and toys all intending to help interact with and teach young children.
The manager,approached me; I explained to him how my daughter and I had enjoyed doing puzzles together, and that I was very fond of the discounts and customer service at their store. But, I was rather disappointed that the store had given me two halves of a whole puzzle, with mis-matched pieces.
The manager and other store personnel smiled and chuckled a little. Clearly I was ignorant about something. “My dear,” he responded, “That is how all of our puzzles are sold.”
“I beg your pardon?” I was, to say the least, confused.
He led me over to the puzzle room in the store, filled with boxes of beautiful jigsaws. There were a few small wooden tables with a few of their demo puzzles laid about the table. Children and adults of all ages gathered at them trying to piece them together.
He walked me to one of the demos
“As you can see Miss, this puzzle here has a picture of a cat and her kitty litter on the box. But, when you examine the pieces, you will see that it is also meshed with a beautiful winter scene.”
I was still puzzled (pun intended). “How can you ever complete a puzzle if you only have two halves in the box, as beautiful as each picture might have originally been?”
“Ahh that is where you are mistaken, Miss” he replied. “These puzzles are just as beautiful, if not even more so, than they were in their originality. The mixture offers the ability to be creative and make the puzzle you want to make. It gives freedom, and takes away from the restrictions originally imposed.”
“I’m sorry,” I replied, “But that simply doesn’t make sense to me. The creators of the puzzles intended for them to be made and put together a certain way. If you mix them with another picture, they simply won’t fit- they were not intended to.”
He interjected, “They may not fit as they had traditionally, in the past. But times are changing. There are many views and perspectives. We want all of our customers to be able to create the puzzle they want to make, without boundaries.”
I was worn out from the manager’s answers. “Well,” I asked, “Could you show me where the puzzles are which have all of the original pieces in them?”
“I’m afraid we don’t have those.” he replied. “Our educational puzzles ensure that children and parents can interact with various different perspectives. This is a pluralistic culture, you see, and we don’t want to be giving the idea that there is one right way of doing things.”
“So I either need to do one of these mixed puzzles with my daughter...or I can’t do a puzzle?”
“Yes, Miss. We find that to be in the best interest of the child.”